Thursday, March 10, 2011

no suspension for chara

The Chara hit on Pacioretty has been a big topic for the last couple of days, and so it should be.  Max Pacioretty is still in a Montreal hospital suffering with a severe concussion and a fractured vertebrae.  Chara received a 5 minute major for interference and a game misconduct for the hit, but was given no supplemental discipline from the league.  A report out of Quebec today stated that the Montreal police are investigating the incident, but to me this is a waste of time.  Yes it was a brutal hit, which probably deserved a suspension, but in no way can anyone prove this was intentional.  Only Zdeno Chara knows what was running through his mind at the time.  In my mind there are a few flaws in the NHL's discipline system.  Firstly, they base way too much of it on reputation.  If that was Steve Downie making the hit, he would have received a minimum of 5 games.  Also, the league stated that they didn't think there was malicious intent from Chara during the hit, the key word there being intent.  How do you define intent?  No one will ever know if Chara meant to do it or not, as there was a bit of a history between the two players as I have mentioned in a previous post, but for someone in the front office in the league to look at the play and  write it off as an accident is just wrong.  The bottom line is that Chara made a careless play at a very dangerous part of the ice, which resulted in a player being severely injured.  How is this any different from the countless headshots and hits from behind we have seen this season?  An open ice headshot is usually not the intended result of the player making the hit, but the game moves so fast now and a split second can turn a big hit into a devastating one.  The league has made a point of it this year to make players accountable for their actions, and I think they really dropped the ball on the Chara incident.  Enough of this intent garbage, if you make a careless play like that you should pay the price.  Pacioretty could have been killed from that hit.  Chara is an 11 year veteran of the league, has played countless games at the Bell Center playing with both Ottawa and Boston, so don't try to tell me he didn't know where he was on the ice.  The league really needs to get some ground rules on hits like this, as the suspensions we have seen handed out this season have been all over the map.  I mean honestly, if a little Trevor Gillies forearm to the head of Clutterbuck warrants a 10 game suspension and this gets nothing, shouldn't the league reconsider their discipline policy?

1 comment:

  1. I can’t believe Chara’s hit is under investigation by Montreal police! It happened at a strange spot on the rink, and that’s why Pacioretty was badly injured. Do the police get involved whenever two players fight on the ice? No, so why should this situation be treated any differently? There is a certain level of physicality that is acceptable for participants in sporting events that wouldn’t be tolerated elsewhere. I hope Chara isn’t criminally charged since it will result in all physical contact in hockey (and other sports) being scrutinized.

    ReplyDelete